Infrastructure & Cities

Air pollution is a concern for every city

March 06, 2015

Africa

March 06, 2015

Africa
James Chambers

Former senior editor

James is Bureau Chief for Monocle, Hong Kong. Prior to this he worked as a Senior Editor with The EIU's Thought Leadership team for over three years researching business, technology and cities. He has also written about business and technology for The World In 2015 and economist.com. James has previous experience from IR magazine, a finance publication, where he was research editor in London and Shanghai. Additionally he contributed to Legal Week, a weekly legal magazine, and worked on the FT Innovative Lawyers Awards in the US and Europe. James is an English law-qualified solicitor (currently non-practising) and holds post-graduate legal qualifications from BPP Law School and an LLP in Law from the London School of Economics.

Chinese and Indian cities are rightly criticised for poor air quality but that is no reason for other cities to breathe easy

Bashing Beijing about poor air quality has become a global pastime, only tempered in recent weeks by adding Delhi and Mumbai into the mix. But as India challenges China for the title of having the world’s dirtiest skies the Beijing government looks increasingly willing to let this one slip away.

Under the Dome, the recent film on Chinese population that went viral, has ratcheted up the pressure on the government, prompting it to make a very public show of determination. Any initiative from the top will demand quick results. And China was already making some progress.

The government now reports air quality data, however accurate; regional governors are being weaned off pure GDP targets, while subway systems are being rolled out across first and second tier cities.

Symbolic clean-ups will also continue. Expect the skies above Beijing to be blue again in time for the World Championships in Athletics in July—the first significant event at the Bird’s Nest stadium since the 2008 Olympics.

Admittedly the size of Beijing’s task is enormous. This was underlined in cruel irony when its most polluted city was revealed to be the epicentre of solar panel manufacturing. But at the same time the extent of the problems affecting Chinese and Indian cities is warping our own sense of safety.

Those of us outside China feel content by comparison. But being able to run a city marathon without a face mask does not warrant a pat on the back. Beijing should not be the benchmark. The World Health Organization collects data on 1600 cities worldwide. On aggregate only 12% of these people live in cities that meet the WHO’s guidelines.  

World cities like Paris and London suffer recurring air quality issues with little, lasting public outcry. In Hong Kong this false sense of security is as chronic as the coughing on the streets. Around Chinese New Year the same local newspapers reporting about the dangerous smog in China were fawning over the festive fog obscuring Hong Kong’s famous skyline. This was in spite of air quality in Hong Kong actually being worse than Beijing—for the second time in as many weeks.

The extent of this ‘better than Beijing’ syndrome became apparent when we launched our Safe Cities Index 2015. One of the reasons Hong Kong falls outside of the top 10 safest cities is air pollution. It ranks mid-table for air quality, alongside Jakarta (based on the WHO data referred to above). But this explanation was given short shrift by local radio hosts, largely because Hong Kong is not as polluted as the mainland.

Notwithstanding the questionable validity of this assumption, international cities like Hong Kong should aspire to a higher standard.

Tokyo, for instance, comes top of our Index. The largest city in the world (by some estimates) also makes it into the top 10 of the air quality indicator. Improvements are likely to continue as the Japanese capital undergoes huge investment ahead of  the 2020 Olympic Games. Yoichi Masuzoe, governor of Tokyo, is committed to demotorisation: ring roads are being built, subsidies for hydrogen cars introduced and pedestrian-only areas rolled out.

The latest Hong Kong budget once again outlined the administration’s desire to improve the city’s environment. Diesel cars are being taken off the road and the odd electric taxi can now be spotted on congested streets. However, real change will only come when the public expects more than just being better than the mainland. Such apathy could prove costly. Beijing is currently close to bottom of the air quality indicator but a determined central government could soon close this gap.

The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited (EIU) or any other member of The Economist Group. The Economist Group (including the EIU) cannot accept any responsibility or liability for reliance by any person on this article or any of the information, opinions or conclusions set out in the article.

 

Enjoy in-depth insights and expert analysis - subscribe to our Perspectives newsletter, delivered every week